Hay moisture testing before baling grass hay into round bales with net wrap

Hay making comes down to one number. Not yield, not cutting date, not even species. Moisture content at the moment the baler closes is what decides whether a field of forage becomes twelve months of feed or a mouldy, heating stack that someone has to dispose of.

The window is narrower than most people expect, and it moves depending on what kind of bale you are making. Too wet and the hay heats, moulds and can catch fire on its own. Too dry and the leaves, which hold most of the protein, shatter off the stems and blow away before they ever reach an animal.

This guide covers the hay moisture targets that actually apply, how to measure moisture properly rather than by feel, what happens on either side of the window, and the point at which the sensible decision is to stop making hay and make baleage instead.

First, Hay Does Not Ferment

Worth settling before anything else, because this confusion causes real losses.

Hay is preserved by desiccation. You remove water until the moisture content is too low for bacteria, yeasts and moulds to be active, and the feed then keeps because nothing can grow in it. There is no fermentation stage in hay making, no lactic acid produced, and no anaerobic seal required.

Silage and baleage work on the opposite principle. The forage stays wet, oxygen is excluded, and lactic acid bacteria ferment plant sugars into acid that drops the pH and preserves the crop. That process needs an airtight barrier and will fail without one.

The practical consequence: dry hay and baleage need different moisture, different packaging and different storage. Treating hay as though it ferments leads people to wrap dry bales in airtight stretch film, which traps whatever residual moisture is in the bale against the hay and produces mould in a package that should have been breathable.

The Correct Sequence for Making Hay

The order of operations matters, and it is frequently stated backwards.

  1. Mow standing green forage. You cut living plants at roughly 75 to 85 percent moisture. You do not wait for a standing crop to dry in the field and then cut it. Standing forage does not cure; it simply matures and loses quality.
  2. Spread the swath for drying. Tedding and conditioning open the material so air and sun reach it. A wide, thin swath dries far faster than a narrow rope of grass.
  3. Turn or ted as needed. This exposes the underside and evens out drying, which is where the article’s original advice was sound.
  4. Rake into windrows at the right moisture. Raking too dry is the single biggest cause of leaf loss in legume hay.
  5. Measure moisture, then bale. Not the reverse.
  6. Store off the ground and covered. More on this below, with real loss figures.

Field curing of grass hay commonly takes three to five days in decent weather, longer in humid conditions or heavy crops. The three-day figure is a reasonable expectation for the drying phase. It is not a waiting period before mowing.

Hay Moisture Targets by Bale Type

There is no single correct baling moisture, because the risk depends on how much heat a bale can shed. A small square bale is mostly surface area and dumps heat easily. A large round or large square bale is dense, has little surface relative to its mass, and holds heat for weeks.

Bale Type Maximum Safe Moisture Why the Limit Differs Packaging
Small rectangular (square) bales Below 22% High surface area per unit mass; sheds heat quickly Baler twine
Large round bales Below 18% Dense core retains heat for weeks after baling Net wrap preferred over twine
Large rectangular bales Below 18% Highest density of all; least able to dissipate heat Baler twine, high wrap count
Baleage / haylage (not dry hay) 40-55% target Preserved by fermentation, not dryness Net wrap plus airtight stretch film

Thresholds for dry hay follow Kansas State University Research and Extension, which also advises that hay baled above 22 percent should sit for at least 30 days before being stacked several layers deep.

The lower boundary gets less attention and costs real money. Below roughly 15 percent, hay is brittle. In legumes such as alfalfa and clover the leaves snap off during raking and baling, and because leaves carry the bulk of the protein, a visually intact bale can have lost a large share of its feed value to the field. Grass hay tolerates dryness better than legumes, but the principle holds: there is such a thing as too dry.

So the working window for round bales sits roughly between 15 and 18 percent. That is narrow, and it is why measurement matters more than instinct.

How to Measure Hay Moisture Properly

Four methods, in ascending order of accuracy and descending order of convenience.

Field hand tests

Useful for a rough read while deciding when to rake, not for deciding when to bale. The twist test is the most reliable version: twist a handful of stems into a rope. If moisture beads or the stems feel slippery, the crop is still too wet. The fingernail scrape test checks whether the stem epidermis still peels. Stems that snap cleanly rather than bending indicate the crop is approaching baling dryness.

The description “dry but not easily crushed by hand” is too vague to act on. Hands tell you roughly where you are; they cannot distinguish 17 percent from 21 percent, and that difference decides whether a bale keeps.

Handheld probe meter

The practical standard. A probe pushed into the windrow or into a finished bale gives an immediate reading. Two cautions: take multiple readings, because moisture varies enormously between the top and bottom of a windrow and between the outside and core of a bale; and treat the reading as a guide at the extremes, since most probes lose accuracy above about 30 percent.

Baler-mounted sensor

Continuous readings as the crop enters the chamber, which is the only way to catch a wet patch in real time. Worth the cost on any operation baling significant tonnage, particularly where preservative is being applied at variable rates.

Oven or microwave drying

The reference method. Weigh a sample, dry it fully, weigh it again, and calculate moisture from the weight lost. Slow, but it is the only approach that gives a defensible number, and it is worth doing a few times each season to check what your probe is actually telling you.

What Goes Wrong Above the Window: Heating and Fire

Stretch wrap film applied to high moisture grass bales for haylage and baleage

Hay baled too wet does not simply mould. It generates heat, and the process can run away.

Residual plant respiration and microbial activity in damp hay release heat. In a dense bale that heat cannot escape, so the core temperature climbs. Above a certain point chemical reactions take over from biological ones and continue heating the mass even after the microbes have died. Most hay fires happen within six weeks of baling, which is precisely the window in which nobody is paying attention any more.

Kansas State Extension gives clear action thresholds for internal hay temperature:

Internal Temperature What It Means What to Do
Below 130°F (54°C) Normal post-baling heating Keep checking twice a day
130-140°F (54-60°C) May rise or fall from here Recheck within a few hours
150°F (66°C) Likely to keep climbing Move hay for air circulation; check every 2 hours
175°F (79°C) and above Fire imminent or already present Call the fire service. Do not move burning hay

Other warning signs are easy to recognise once you know them: a caramel or burnt-sugar smell, visible vapour rising off a stack on a cool morning, a strong musty odour, or bales that feel hot to the hand. Bales commonly go through several heating and cooling cycles, each peak lower than the last, which is a sign the hay is stabilising.

One point that is counterintuitive and important: do not move hay that shows signs of active fire. Opening a smouldering stack admits oxygen and can turn a slow burn into a flame front.

Baling Slightly Wet on Purpose: Hay Preservatives

Sometimes the weather does not cooperate and the choice is between baling at 22 percent or losing the crop to rain. Organic acid preservatives exist for exactly this situation.

Guidance from University of Wisconsin Extension:

  • Propionic acid is the effective ingredient. Acetic acid works too but is roughly half as effective.
  • Ammonium propionate, a buffered form, is preferred over raw propionic acid because it is far less caustic and much less corrosive to machinery.
  • Rates are quoted as pounds of propionate per ton of dry matter: about 8 lb/ton for hay under 18 percent moisture, rising to about 20 lb/ton for hay over 25 percent. Read the label carefully, because a product that is 50 percent propionate needs twice the listed rate of product.
  • Above about 35 percent moisture, preservative treatment is not recommended. At that point the crop belongs in baleage, not in dry bales.
  • Microbial hay inoculants have not been shown to work. Products other than organic acids do little to preserve dry hay.
  • Preservatives are unnecessary for baleage, since the wrap already excludes the oxygen mould needs.

Desiccants are a different tool, used before baling rather than at it. Potassium or sodium carbonate disturbs the waxy cuticle on legume stems so they dry faster. They work on alfalfa, trefoil and clovers but not on grasses, they only help in good drying weather, and the volume of water needed to apply them means they are seldom used in practice.

Storage: Where Good Hay Moisture Gets Undone

A bale made at the right moisture can still be ruined by where it sits. The original version of this article cited loss figures of around 10 and 15 percent for various practices. The real numbers are both larger and better documented. Oklahoma State University Extension reports:

Storage Method DM Loss up to 9 Months DM Loss at 12-18 Months
Exposed, sitting on the ground 5-20% 15-50%
Exposed, elevated off the ground 3-15% 12-35%
Covered, on the ground 5-10% 10-15%
Covered and elevated 2-4% 5-10%
Under a roof 2-5% 3-10%
Enclosed barn Under 2% 2-5%

Two findings from that work deserve emphasis. Ground contact alone can account for more than half of total dry matter loss, and moisture wicking up from soil can destroy as much as the bottom 12 inches of a bale. Elevating bales on pallets, old timbers or a six-inch crushed rock pad is one of the cheapest improvements available to anyone storing hay outdoors.

On wrapping, Oklahoma State found net-wrapped bales have storage losses similar to twine when outer-layer density is comparable, and that net wrap sheds water better. Where twine is used, wraps should sit no more than eight inches apart, and preferably six.

A note on tarps, since the original article claimed covering will not change hay moisture. A tarp over bales that are still sitting on damp soil traps rising moisture underneath and can make the bottom of the stack worse, not better. Cover and elevate together, or the cover does only half a job.

When You Cannot Get Dry: Switch to Baleage

This is the decision point the original article missed entirely, and it is the one that actually saves crops in wet climates.

If the forecast will not give you the three to five clear days that dry hay needs, trying to make hay anyway produces either rained-on hay with heavy nutrient loss or a bale too wet to keep. The alternative is to stop aiming for 18 percent and aim for 40 to 55 percent instead, wrap the bale airtight, and let it ferment.

Baleage is not hay with plastic on it. It is a different preservation system:

  • Wilt for hours, not days. One good drying day is usually enough to get from 80 percent down to the 40 to 55 percent range.
  • Bale densely. Loose baleage traps air and ferments poorly.
  • Wrap promptly and completely. Wrapping within a few hours of baling matters; oxygen left inside is what feeds mould and yeast.
  • Use enough film layers. Four to six is standard, more for crops that will be stored long or handled often.
  • Consider an inoculant for legumes and mature grasses, which carry less sugar and buffer more strongly against the pH drop fermentation needs.

The trade-off is honest: baleage weighs more per bale, is harder to transport, and is unforgiving of a torn wrap. In exchange it removes almost all of the weather risk that makes hay making stressful.

Matching Packaging to the Moisture You Actually Have

Everything above reduces to one question at the baler: is this crop preserved by being dry, or by being sealed?

Dry, at or below 18 percent. The bale needs to be held in shape and kept breathable. That means baler twine or bale net wrap, plus elevation and a cover. Sealing dry hay in airtight film is a mistake: it traps residual moisture against the hay with nowhere to go.

Wet, at 40 to 55 percent. The bale needs an oxygen barrier. That means net wrap to hold the shape plus multiple layers of stretch film to seal it.

Silopak manufactures for both routes and has exported since 2011. For baleage and silage we supply virgin LLDPE silage film at 25 microns in 750 mm × 1500 m, 500 mm × 1800 m and 250 mm × 1800 m, with a 12-month UV guarantee and field life typically beyond 18 months. For dry hay and straw we supply 100 percent HDPE UV-stabilised bale net wrap in 0.52 m, 1.05 m, 1.23 m and 1.25 m widths, and polypropylene baler twine across the common tensile grades.

Machinery is a separate matter. Balers and combi baler wrappers come from our group company jummos.com; Silopak itself makes films, net wrap, twine and silage additives, not equipment. Tell us which moisture range you are working in and we will quote the right consumable rather than the most expensive one.

Frequently Asked Questions about Hay Moisture

Q: What is the ideal moisture content for baling hay?

It depends on bale type, because density determines how fast heat escapes. Kansas State Extension recommends below 22 percent for small rectangular bales and below 18 percent for large round and large rectangular bales, which hold heat far longer. The practical working window for round bales is roughly 15 to 18 percent: wet enough that leaves stay attached, dry enough that the bale will not heat. Baleage is an entirely different target at 40 to 55 percent, since it is preserved by fermentation rather than dryness.

Q: Can hay be too dry?

Yes, and in legumes it is expensive. Below about 15 percent moisture the plant becomes brittle and leaves shatter off the stems during raking and baling. Since leaves carry the majority of the protein in alfalfa and clover, hay that looks perfect can have lost a substantial share of its feeding value to the ground. Grass hay is more forgiving because its leaves attach more firmly. Raking in the early morning while a little dew remains is a standard way to limit leaf loss.

Q: Does hay ferment like silage?

No. Hay is preserved by removing water until microbial activity stops, a process called desiccation. Silage and baleage are preserved by anaerobic fermentation, where lactic acid bacteria convert plant sugars into acid that lowers pH in a sealed environment. The two systems have different moisture targets, different packaging requirements and different failure modes, and confusing them leads to wrapping dry hay in airtight film, which traps residual moisture and causes mould.

Q: How do I know if my hay is heating dangerously?

Measure internal temperature with a probe thermometer pushed into the stack rather than relying on touch. Below 130°F (54°C) is normal post-baling heating and only needs twice-daily checks. At 130 to 140°F recheck within hours. At 150°F (66°C) the temperature is likely to keep climbing, so move the hay to improve air circulation and check every two hours. At 175°F (79°C) or above, fire is imminent or already present: call the fire service and do not move the hay, because disturbing it admits oxygen. Monitor for about six weeks after baling, since that is when most hay fires occur.

Q: Can I bale wet hay if I use a preservative?

Within limits. Buffered propionic acid products allow safe baling at moisture levels somewhat above the normal ceiling, applied at roughly 8 lb of propionate per ton of dry matter below 18 percent moisture and around 20 lb/ton above 25 percent. Check whether the rate on the label is product or active ingredient, since a 50 percent propionate product needs double. Above about 35 percent moisture, preservatives are not recommended and the crop should go into baleage instead. Microbial hay inoculants have not been shown to preserve dry hay.

Q: What is the best way to store round bales to protect hay moisture?

Covered and elevated, which Oklahoma State Extension associates with 2 to 4 percent dry matter loss up to nine months, against 5 to 20 percent for bales left exposed on the ground and 15 to 50 percent for exposed ground storage held 12 to 18 months. Ground contact alone can account for over half of total loss, and soil moisture wicking upward can destroy up to the bottom 12 inches of a bale. If a shed is not available, put bales on pallets, timbers or a six-inch crushed rock pad and cover the top. Covering without elevating traps rising moisture and only solves half the problem.

Q: Should I use net wrap or twine for dry hay?

Both work, and Oklahoma State found similar storage losses when outer-layer density is comparable, though net wrap sheds water better and is faster through the baler. Net wrap also produces a tighter, more weather-resistant outer surface, which matters most for bales stored outdoors. If using twine, keep wraps no more than eight inches apart and preferably six. What neither should be confused with is stretch film, which is for sealing high-moisture baleage and is the wrong product for dry hay.


Reviewed by Sue Su, Marketing Director of Silopak, on 18 October 2026. Moisture ceilings assume a reasonably dense bale and normal storage; in humid climates work toward the lower end of every range given here.